“It's on Time That They Assimilate” – Differential acculturation expectations towards first and second generation immigrants
In an experiment with 187 Germans, majority members tolerated biculturalism less in immigrants born in the country than in newcomers — and demanded assimilation specifically from the second generation of the devalued group, German-Turks. Exactly the immigrants most committed to their heritage culture face the strongest pressure to shed it.
The paper, in plain language
Adding the generation question
Research on what majorities expect of immigrants had compared valued and devalued groups but ignored generation — odd, when a third of Germany's immigrant-background population was born there. With David Sam, I had German majority members rate their acculturation expectations toward first- and second-generation targets from a devalued group, Turks, and a more neutral one, Poles.
Less room for the second generation
Across target groups, participants endorsed less integrationism toward the second generation: tolerance for keeping heritage culture shrinks once you are born in Germany. The interaction sharpens it — assimilation demands rose for second-generation Turks specifically, not for Poles. The title's logic: if you were born here and are staying, you should become one of us. Our companion work shows second-generation Turkish youth perceive exactly this pressure — and are also the group most committed to cultural maintenance. The effects are modest, the proposed threat mechanism was not measured, and generation is partly confounded with age.
Why it matters
The interactive acculturation framework predicts conflict where majority expectations and minority preferences collide, and this collision is head-on: rising assimilation demands meeting a settled preference for cultural maintenance. It reframes second-generation 'integration problems' as partly a majority-side production, and it was an early piece of the research line that grew into my work on majority-group acculturation and the expectations majorities impose.
Kunst, J. R., & Sam, D. L. (2014). “It’s on time that they assimilate” – Differential acculturation expectations towards first and second generation immigrants. International Journal of Intercultural Relations, 39, 188-195. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijintrel.2013.10.007